Do Insurance Companies Want to Settle Out of Court?

November 25, 2024 | By Ted R. Lorenz
Do Insurance Companies Want to Settle Out of Court?

When you've suffered an injury in an accident, you might be facing a mountain of medical bills, lost income, and other expenses. On top of that, you're likely dealing with pain, stress, and uncertainty about the future. In this tough situation, you'll probably have to deal with an insurance company. You might wonder: do they want to settle your case, or are they hoping to take it to court?

The truth is that insurance companies usually prefer to settle cases and not go to court. But that doesn't always mean they'll offer you a fair deal right away.

It's good to understand why insurance companies often want to settle early. And, why having a personal injury attorney on your side can make a significant difference. Sometimes, cases go to court and knowing why that might be the best option for you, is important, too.

Click for free case review

Getting Proper Medical Care After an Accident

After you've been in an accident, your health should be your top priority. Even if you don't think you're badly hurt, it's important to see a doctor right away. Some injuries might not show up immediately, but a medical expert can spot signs of hidden problems. They'll make sure you get the right treatment from the start.

Seeing a doctor quickly also creates a record of your injuries. This can be very helpful later on if you need to show how the accident affected you. The doctor's notes will describe your condition right after the accident happened.

Remember, your well-being comes first. Don't try to tough it out or assume you'll feel better on your own. Let a medical professional check you out and guide your recovery. This is a key step in taking care of yourself after an accident.

What Are the Goals of the Insurance Company?

Insurance companies are businesses, and like all businesses, they want to make money. When someone gets hurt in an accident, the insurance company's main goal is usually to pay out as little as possible. They might try to settle quickly before you really know how bad your injuries are or how much your treatment will cost.

These companies have teams of people who work on accident claims every day. They know lots of ways to reduce the amount they have to pay. Sometimes, they might offer a settlement that seems good at first but isn't nearly enough to cover all your damages in the long run.

It's hard for most people to know if an insurance offer is fair. That's why it's best to talk to a personal injury lawyer before agreeing to anything. They can look at your case and tell you if the offer is reasonable or if you should ask for more.

Why Insurance Companies Often Prefer to Settle

Most of the time, insurance companies would rather settle a case than go to court. There are several reasons for this:

  • Going to court costs a lot of money. The insurance company has to pay lawyers, prepare discovery, and spend time getting ready for trial. All of this adds up quickly.
  • Court cases can take a long time, sometimes years. Insurance companies usually want to close cases as fast as they can.
  • When a case goes to court, the result is unpredictable. A jury might decide to award a much larger amount than the insurance company wanted to pay. By settling out of court, the insurance company has more control over how much they spend.
  • Trials are public. Insurance companies often prefer to keep the details of accidents and payouts private. Settling out of court lets them do this.

Because of these factors, many insurance companies will try hard to reach a settlement before a case gets to court. But that doesn't mean their first offer, or even their second or third, will be fair to you.

The Role of a Personal Injury Lawyer

This is where a personal injury lawyer becomes extremely valuable. They know how insurance companies work and what tricks they might use. A good personal injury lawyer can:

  • Figure out the true cost of your injuries, including future medical care you might need
  • Gather evidence to show how the accident has affected your life
  • Negotiate with the insurance company to get you a fair settlement
  • Take your case to court if the insurance company won't offer enough money

Having a personal injury lawyer on your side can make a big difference in how much money you receive. Insurance companies often offer more when they know you have a lawyer helping you.

The Process of Settling Out of Court

Settling a case out of court usually involves several steps. First, your personal injury attorney will send a demand letter to the insurance company. This letter explains your injuries, how the accident happened, and how much money you're asking for.

The insurance company will review this letter and probably make a counteroffer. This is usually lower than what you asked for. Your lawyer will discuss this offer with you and help you decide if it's fair.

If it's not fair, your lawyer will negotiate with the insurance company. This can go back and forth several times. Your lawyer will keep you informed and get your okay before accepting any offer.

If you and the insurance company can agree on an amount, you'll sign a settlement agreement. This document says you accept the money and won't try to get more later. Once you sign this and get your payment, your case is over.

When Cases Go to Court

Sometimes, insurance companies won't offer a fair settlement. When this happens, your personal injury attorney might advise you to file a lawsuit and take your case to court.

Going to court doesn't mean you'll definitely have a trial. Many cases settle during the court process before reaching a trial. The threat of going to court can sometimes make insurance companies more willing to offer a fair settlement.

If your case goes to trial, your personal injury lawyer will present evidence showing how you suffered the injury and why you deserve compensation. The insurance company's lawyers will try to argue against this. In the end, a judge or jury will decide how much money, if any, you should receive.

Trials can be stressful and take a long time. But sometimes they're necessary to get the compensation you deserve. A good personal injury lawyer will help you understand your options and support you through the process.

Learn more: What Are the Chances of Winning a Personal Injury Lawsuit?

Factors That Affect Settlement Amounts

Many things can influence how much money you might get in a settlement. Some of these include:

  • How bad your injuries are and how long they'll affect you
  • Whether you'll need ongoing medical care
  • If you had to miss work because of your injuries
  • Whether the accident left you with any permanent disabilities
  • How clear it is that the other person was at fault
  • The limits of the insurance policy involved

Your personal injury lawyer will consider all these factors when deciding how much money to ask for. They'll also consider similar cases in your area to see what kind of settlements or verdicts they received.

Remember, every case is different. What someone else got for their accident might not be right for your situation. That's why it's so important to have a personal injury lawyer who can evaluate your specific case.

Dealing with Insurance Company Tactics

Insurance companies have many ways to try to pay less on claims. They might:

  • Question whether your injuries are really from the accident
  • Suggest that you're exaggerating how badly you're hurt
  • Try to blame you for part or all of the accident
  • Delay responding to your claim, hoping you'll get frustrated and accept a low offer
  • Pressure you to give a recorded statement, which they might use against you later

A personal injury lawyer knows all these tactics and how to deal with them. They can protect you from saying something that might hurt your case. They'll also make sure the insurance company doesn't ignore or unfairly deny your claim.

The Cost of Hiring a Personal Injury Lawyer

Many people worry about how much it costs to hire a personal injury lawyer. The good news is that most personal injury lawyers work on what's called a "contingency fee" basis. This means you don't pay them upfront.

Instead, the lawyer gets a percentage of the money they win for you. If they don't win your case, you don't owe them anything for their work. This system lets anyone get legal help, no matter how much money they have.

Keeping Records to Support Your Case

While your personal injury lawyer will do a lot of work on your case, there are things you can do to help. One of the most important is keeping good records.

Save all your medical bills and receipts for other expenses related to your accident. This can include parking fees for doctor visits or the cost of hiring someone to help with chores you can't do because of your injuries.

Keep a journal about how your injuries affect your daily life. Write down when you have pain, what activities you can't do, and how you're feeling. This can help show the full impact of the accident on your life.

If you have to miss work, keep track of the days and how much pay you lost. Your personal injury lawyer can use all this information to argue for a higher settlement.

The Emotional Impact of Accidents

Accidents don't just cause physical injuries. They can also affect you emotionally. You might feel scared, angry, or suffer from PTSD. Some people have trouble sleeping or feel anxious about doing things they used to enjoy.

These emotional effects are real and important. They're part of the overall harm the accident caused you. A good personal injury lawyer will include these issues when calculating how much compensation you should get.

Understanding the Statute of Limitations

Every state has laws about how long you have to start a legal case after an accident. This is called the statute of limitations. If you wait too long, you might lose your right to seek compensation.

The exact time limit varies depending on what kind of accident you had and where it happened. In some states, you might have as little as one year. In others, you could have several years. Therefore, it's best not to wait until the last minute to talk to a personal injury lawyer.

Even if you think you might be close to the time limit, it's worth calling a personal injury lawyer. They can tell you if you still have time to file a claim.

What to Expect During Settlement Negotiations

When your personal injury lawyer starts negotiating with the insurance company, they'll keep you informed about what's happening. Your lawyer will let you know about any settlement offers. They'll explain what they think of the offer and whether they think you should accept it or keep negotiating. The final decision will always be up to you.

During this time, it's important to keep following your doctor's advice and attending all your medical appointments. This shows that you're serious about your recovery and helps support your claim for compensation.

When Settlement Isn't Possible

While most personal injury cases settle out of court, sometimes going to trial is necessary. This might happen if the insurance company refuses to offer a fair settlement or if there's a dispute about who was at fault for the accident.

If your case goes to trial, your personal injury lawyer will prepare you for what to expect. They'll explain the court process and how to present your story to the judge and jury.

Trials can be stressful, but remember that your lawyer will be there to support you every step of the way. They'll present evidence, question witnesses, and argue your case to the court. Even if your case starts moving towards a trial, settlement is still possible.

Life After Settlement

Once you reach a settlement or win your case in court, you'll receive your compensation. Your personal injury lawyer will help make sure you receive your money promptly. They'll also explain any tax implications of your settlement. In many cases, money received for physical injuries isn't taxable, but there can be exceptions.

Remember that this money is meant to cover your expenses and losses from the accident. It's a good idea to set some aside for any future medical care you might need. Your lawyer or a financial advisor can help you plan how to use your settlement wisely.

Don't Wait to Get Help After an Accident

If you've been in an accident, don't wait to get legal help. Most personal injury lawyers offer free consultations so you can get advice about your situation without any cost or commitment. The sooner you talk to a lawyer, the sooner they can start working to protect your rights and pursue the compensation you need.

Click for free case review

Ted R. Lorenz Author Image

Ted R. Lorenz

Founder & Attorney

Author's Bio