You were in a motorcycle accident that completely destroyed your bike. Now you’re wondering what happens when the insurance company totals your motorcycle. It’s a question no rider ever wants to face, but unfortunately, it’s a reality for you.

Your motorcycle was more than just a means of transportation. It was a part of your lifestyle and a source of freedom and joy. Now, you’re left dealing with insurance companies and trying to navigate the complex claims process while still reeling from the accident itself.

If someone else caused the motorcycle wreck through their negligence or wrongdoing, you could obtain compensation from them, especially if you suffered injuries. Whether you’re dealing with your own motorcycle insurance company or the at-fault party’s insurer, you need to understand how insurance companies total vehicles and how you can protect your rights and interests.

For help getting the full financial recovery you need to replace your bike and cover the costs of your injuries, contact a motorcycle accident lawyer near you today for a free consultation.

What Does It Mean When the Insurance Company Totals a Motorcycle?

toy motorcycle and calculator on purple background

Hearing that your motorcycle has been “totaled” can be a gut punch. What does this term really mean, though, and how do insurance companies make this determination?

Definition of a Total Loss

When an insurance company declares your motorcycle a “total loss,” they’ve essentially decided that repairing the bike would cost more than it’s worth. In other words, from their perspective, it makes more financial sense to pay you the value of the motorcycle rather than cover the cost of repairs.

Insurance Company’s Criteria for Determining a Total Loss

Each insurance company has its own specific formula for determining when a vehicle is a total loss. Although thresholds and other factors may vary, it generally comes down to a simple equation: If the cost of repairs plus the salvage value of the motorcycle exceeds the actual cash value of the bike before the accident, the insurance company will likely consider it a total loss.

Factors Insurers Consider

Insurance adjusters look at several factors when determining whether to total a vehicle:

  • Cost of repairs: This includes parts, labor, and any other expenses required to restore the motorcycle to its pre-accident condition.
  • Motorcycle’s pre-accident value: They’ll consider the make, model, year, mileage, and overall condition of your bike before the crash.
  • Salvage value: This is what the insurance company could get for selling the damaged motorcycle for parts.
  • Safety concerns: Even if repairs are technically possible, if there are significant safety issues (like frame damage), the insurer may opt to total the bike.
  • State regulations: Some states have specific rules about when a vehicle must be declared a total loss.

Understanding these factors can help you and your attorney better navigate discussions with the insurance company and ensure you’re getting a fair deal.

Evaluating the Insurance Company’s Settlement Offer

Once they declare your motorcycle a total loss, the insurance company will present you with a settlement offer. How do they arrive at this number, and is it fair? Let’s explore the process and your options.

How the Insurance Company Calculates the Motorcycle’s Value

Insurance companies use various methods to determine your motorcycle’s value, including:

  • Comparable sales: They’ll look at recent sales of similar motorcycles in your area.
  • Kelley Blue Book or NADA Guides: These resources provide estimated values based on make, model, year, and condition.
  • Dealer quotes: They might contact local dealerships to get quotes on comparable bikes.
  • Your motorcycle’s specific features and condition: Any upgrades, customizations, or recent maintenance can affect the value.

Actual Cash Value (ACV) vs. Replacement Cost Value (RCV)

Most insurance policies pay out based on Actual Cash Value (ACV), which is the cost to replace your motorcycle minus depreciation. This means you’ll likely get less than what you paid for the bike originally.

Replacement Cost Value (RCV), on the other hand, would cover the cost of replacing your motorcycle with a new one of the same or similar make and model, without factoring in depreciation. While this type of coverage is less common and more expensive, it can be worth considering, especially for newer or high-value motorcycles.

Disagreeing with the Settlement Offer

If you believe the insurance company’s offer is too low, you have the right to dispute it. A motorcycle accident lawyer can assist with this process, which includes:

  • Doing research: Gather evidence of your motorcycle’s value using resources like Kelley Blue Book, recent sales of similar bikes, and dealer quotes.
  • Documenting your bike’s condition: If your motorcycle was in excellent condition or had recent upgrades, provide evidence (receipts, photos) to support a higher valuation.
  • Getting an independent appraisal: Consider hiring a professional appraiser to provide an unbiased valuation of your motorcycle.
  • Presenting your case: Submit a formal request for reconsideration to the insurance company, including all your supporting evidence.

Negotiating with the Insurance Company

Remember, the initial offer is just that – an offer. You have the right to negotiate for a higher settlement if you believe it’s unfair, but you should work with an attorney to negotiate for you to get the best possible results.

Have all your documentation ready for your lawyer before they start negotiations. Emotional arguments won’t sway the insurance adjuster, but facts and evidence might.

Your attorney will present you with any offers. Be willing to compromise, but don’t settle for less than you need. Follow your lawyer’s advice on the fairness of the offer and whether they believe the insurer will offer more.

Should You Keep Your Totaled Motorcycle?

Sometimes, despite the insurance company’s determination, you might want to keep your totaled motorcycle for various reasons, including:

  • Emotional attachment: Your bike might hold special memories or significance.
  • Customizations: If you’ve invested heavily in custom parts, you might want to salvage them.
  • Repair potential: You might believe you can fix the bike for less than the insurance company’s estimate.
  • Collector’s item: Some vintage or rare motorcycles might be worth keeping even in a damaged state.

Whatever the reason, if you decide to keep your totaled motorcycle, you will need to file for a salvage title. This has several important implications:

  • Reduced value: A salvage title significantly decreases a vehicle’s value, often by 20-40%.
  • Insurance challenges: Many insurance companies won’t offer comprehensive or collision coverage for salvage title vehicles.
  • Safety concerns: A salvage title indicates significant damage, which could raise safety issues.
  • Resale difficulties: It can be much harder to sell a motorcycle with a salvage title.

Buying Back Your Motorcycle from the Insurance Company

If you want to keep your totaled bike, you may buy it back from the insurance company. Here’s how the process typically works:

  • Inform the insurance company of your decision to keep the bike.
  • The insurer will determine the salvage value of the motorcycle.
  • They’ll subtract this salvage value from your settlement amount.
  • You’ll receive the reduced settlement and retain ownership of the motorcycle.

For example, if your settlement was $5,000 and the salvage value is $1,000, you’d receive $4,000 and keep the bike.

Remember, if you choose this option, you’ll be responsible for all repairs and for registering the motorcycle with a salvage title. Carefully consider whether the emotional or practical value of keeping the bike outweighs the potential drawbacks.

What About Replacing Your Motorcycle?

After the dust settles and you’ve reached an agreement with the insurance company, you’ll likely be thinking about your next ride. Let’s look at some considerations when it comes to replacing your totaled motorcycle.

Using the Insurance Settlement to Purchase a New Motorcycle

Once you receive your settlement, you’re free to use that money however you choose. If you decide to buy another motorcycle, here are some things to keep in mind:

  • Budget: Your settlement might not cover the full cost of a brand-new bike. Consider whether you’re willing to add your own money to the pot.
  • New vs. Used: A used motorcycle might give you more bang for your buck, but a new one comes with warranties and the latest features.
  • Similar model vs. Upgrade: This could be an opportunity to try a different style of bike if you’ve been thinking about a change.
  • Timing: Motorcycle prices can vary seasonally. If you can wait, you might find better deals in the off-season.

Gap Insurance and Its Role in Covering Replacement Costs

If you financed your totaled motorcycle, you might owe more on the loan than the insurance settlement covers. This is where gap insurance comes in.

Gap insurance covers the difference between what you owe on your motorcycle loan and what your motorcycle is actually worth. For example, if you owe $10,000 on your loan but your totaled bike is only worth $8,000, gap insurance would cover the $2,000 difference.

If you didn’t have gap insurance this time around, consider it for your next motorcycle. It’s valuable coverage, especially if you’re financing a significant portion of the purchase price.

Possible Disputes and Issues to Consider

Even with a clear understanding of the process, disputes can still arise when dealing with a totaled motorcycle claim. Being aware of potential issues can help you and your attorney navigate this complex situation more effectively.

  • Valuation disagreements: You and the insurance company might have different ideas about what your motorcycle was worth.
  • Repair vs. Total loss decisions: You might believe your bike is repairable, while the insurer insists on totaling it.
  • Customization and aftermarket parts: Insurers don’t always fully account for modifications you’ve made to your motorcycle.
  • Depreciation calculations: The rate at which the insurer depreciates your motorcycle’s value can be a point of contention.
  • Rental vehicle coverage: Disputes can arise over how long the insurer will cover a rental vehicle while your claim is being processed.

Hiring an Attorney for Insurance Claims

consulting a lawyer

If you’re facing significant pushback from the insurance company or if you have extensive injuries in addition to your totaled motorcycle, you need to consider legal help. An attorney who handles motorcycle accident cases can:

  • Negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf
  • Account for all your damages and carefully assess your losses
  • Advise you on the fair value of your claim
  • Represent you in court if necessary

Many attorneys offer free initial consultations, so it can be worth exploring this option even if you’re unsure about hiring legal representation.

Filing a Complaint with the State Insurance Commissioner

If you believe the insurance company is acting in bad faith or violating state regulations, you have the right to file a complaint with your state’s insurance commissioner. Again, an attorney can help you through the process, but some things you need to consider to support your case and protect yourself include:

  • Document everything: Keep detailed records of all communications with the insurance company.
  • Know your policy: Make sure you understand what your policy covers before filing a complaint.
  • Be specific: Clearly explain how you believe the insurer has violated your rights or state regulations.
  • Be patient: The resolution process can take time, but it’s an important step in holding insurance companies accountable.

Remember, while disputes can be frustrating, staying calm, focusing on the facts, and working with an attorney when necessary will serve you best as you work toward a fair resolution.

Contact an Experienced Motorcycle Accident Attorney for Help

You have a lot to consider if the insurance company totaled your bike after a motorcycle accident. Keep in mind that insurance companies are businesses. They’re typically more concerned with increasing their profits and making their shareholders happy. They don’t want to pay any more on claims than they have to.

Having an attorney on your side helps level the playing field. A lawyer knows insurance company tactics to reduce the amount they must pay or deny claims altogether. Don’t let them take advantage of you, and don’t settle for less than you need to replace your totaled motorcycle.

The experienced personal injury lawyers at Lorenz & Lorenz, PLLC, are here to help you deal with the insurer and get top-dollar for your motorcycle accident claim. If you suffered injuries in a motorcycle crash someone else caused, you can rely on us to fight hard to help you get the full and fair compensation you deserve.

Contact us today for a free case evaluation and let us handle the legal wranglings while you focus on healing and moving on with your life.